Graubünden Moves to Extend Lower Welfare Payments for Ukrainian Refugees
The Swiss canton of Graubünden is preparing to maintain lower social assistance payments for Ukrainian refugees even after they become eligible for longer-term residence permits, a move that could affect hundreds of people from March 2027.
The cantonal government approved a legislative proposal on November 6, 2026, seeking to preserve the reduced financial support currently provided to people holding Switzerland’s Protection Status S. The proposed arrangement would prevent eligible refugees from automatically receiving the same level of basic social assistance as the general resident population after five years in the country.
The decision comes as Switzerland prepares to change the financial arrangements governing support for Ukrainian refugees, placing additional responsibility on cantonal and municipal authorities. Graubünden wants to establish its own legal framework before the first affected residents reach the five-year threshold.
Five-year milestone brings changes to refugee assistance
Switzerland introduced Protection Status S in response to Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. The special protection arrangement allows eligible people fleeing the war to live in Switzerland without going through the country’s standard asylum procedure.
The status provides temporary protection and access to assistance, including accommodation and financial support under the applicable arrangements.
However, the five-year milestone will bring an important administrative change. Starting in March 2027, the first Ukrainians who arrived under the protection programme will have spent five years in Switzerland and become eligible for a B residence permit.
Under the existing framework, obtaining this permit would generally bring access to the same social assistance arrangements available to other residents.
Graubünden’s government wants to prevent that change from automatically increasing the financial support available to this particular group.
Instead, the canton proposes continuing the existing reduced assistance framework regardless of whether an individual holds Protection Status S or a B residence permit.
The proposal is intended to establish consistent financial support arrangements for people receiving assistance, independently of their residence permit category.
Around 960 people could be affected
Figures included in the cantonal government’s explanatory documentation indicate that approximately 960 people could fall within the scope of the proposed legislative change between March and December 2027.
Of that total, around 640 are currently receiving financial assistance.
The financial implications are significant for local authorities responsible for administering welfare payments.
According to the government’s calculations, municipalities could face approximately CHF 5.4 million in social assistance expenditure during the relevant period if the affected residents were to receive the standard basic allowance.
Maintaining the existing reduced payment arrangement would bring the projected expenditure down to approximately CHF 4.8 million.
That represents an estimated difference of CHF 600,000 over the period covered by the calculations.
Under the proposal, eligible Ukrainian refugees would continue receiving 80% of the standard basic needs allowance. This reflects a 20% reduction compared with the regular rate established under the Swiss Conference for Social Assistance guidelines.
The figures are projections rather than confirmed future spending. Actual expenditure will depend on the number of people receiving assistance and their individual circumstances.
Federal funding changes behind the decision
The Graubünden proposal is also connected to a broader adjustment in Switzerland’s approach to financing assistance for people with temporary protection.
The federal government has approved changes through its 2027 budget relief package that reduce federal financial participation in social assistance costs for people holding Protection Status S beyond the relevant five-year period.
This shifts a greater share of the financial responsibility towards cantons and municipalities.
Previously, federal contributions formed part of the financial arrangements supporting cantonal authorities in providing assistance to people covered by the protection system.
With the funding framework changing, cantonal governments face decisions about how much financial support to provide and how to manage the additional expenditure.
The Federal Council has also pursued changes to Asylum Ordinance 2 to give cantons greater discretion in determining social assistance levels for affected residents.
The proposed framework allows cantons to establish payment arrangements under their own legislation rather than applying a single uniform approach across Switzerland.
Graubünden is among the cantons moving to establish its position ahead of the anticipated changes in March 2027.
Cantonal government defends consistent treatment
Graubünden’s government says its proposed approach is based on maintaining equal financial treatment among people receiving assistance, regardless of their residence permit.
Marcus Caduff, the cantonal government member responsible for economic affairs and social issues, explained the reasoning behind the proposal in the government’s November 6 announcement.
Under the proposed arrangement, people holding a B residence permit would receive the same financial support as those without such a permit.
In practical terms, this means that obtaining a longer-term residence document would not automatically result in an increase in the basic social assistance allowance for Ukrainian refugees covered by the measure.
The government considers this approach consistent with the applicable social assistance guidelines, while retaining the reduced basic allowance already used for this group.
The proposal therefore focuses on the level of financial assistance rather than removing the protection or residence arrangements available to eligible Ukrainians.
Importantly, the measure does not mean that all Ukrainian residents in Graubünden would automatically receive reduced payments. Its application concerns people covered by the relevant social assistance and protection-status arrangements.
Parliament must approve the legislative change
Although the cantonal government has approved the proposal, the measure has not yet become law.
The legislative amendment will be presented to the Graubünden Cantonal Parliament during its December 2026 session.
The government intends to introduce the changes through a partial revision of the canton’s Law on Support for Persons in Need.
It is also seeking an expedited legislative procedure to ensure the new arrangements can take effect by March 1, 2027.
Under the ordinary legislative process, the required referendum period would not leave sufficient time to implement the proposed changes before the five-year milestone.
For that reason, the government wants parliament to declare the legislation urgent.
Such a decision requires support from at least two-thirds of parliamentarians.
The December parliamentary debate will therefore be an important stage in determining whether the proposed financial arrangements can be implemented according to the government’s timetable.
Until the legislative process is completed, the proposal should not be treated as an already enacted change.
Different approaches emerging across Switzerland
Graubünden’s proposal reflects a wider discussion about how Switzerland should support Ukrainian refugees who remain in the country for extended periods.
The federal government has been considering greater flexibility for cantons to determine social assistance payments for people holding Protection Status S beyond five years.
This has opened the possibility of different financial arrangements depending on where refugees live.
Some cantonal authorities have supported the idea of maintaining lower assistance payments, arguing that the changing federal funding structure requires greater control over local expenditure.
However, the proposal has also raised concerns among political parties and humanitarian organisations.
In an October 2026 report, SWI swissinfo.ch described objections from organisations including Caritas, HEKS and Swiss Refugee Aid, which warned that reductions in assistance could increase financial hardship and undermine integration.
They have also raised questions about potential legal challenges and whether different benefit levels could create difficulties in applying Switzerland’s international obligations.
The debate highlights a fundamental policy issue: how Switzerland can balance public expenditure, consistent welfare standards and the long-term integration of people displaced by war.
The different positions also demonstrate that the consequences of the federal changes extend beyond the immediate question of how much assistance individual refugees receive.
What the decision could mean for Ukrainian residents
For Ukrainian refugees receiving financial assistance in Graubünden, the proposed legislation could mean that reaching five years of residence will not bring an increase in their basic social assistance payments.
People affected would continue receiving 80% of the standard basic needs allowance under the proposed arrangement.
The actual impact on individual households would depend on their financial circumstances, family composition and eligibility for assistance.
The proposal also illustrates the distinction between obtaining a different residence permit and gaining access to higher welfare payments. These are separate legal and administrative questions, even when changes to one affect the other.
For municipalities, the decision could help limit additional social assistance expenditure during a period when federal financial contributions are changing.
However, the broader effects on household finances, integration and demand for local support services will depend on how the policy is implemented.
March 2027 deadline approaches
The coming months will determine whether Graubünden can put its proposed arrangements into force before the first affected Ukrainian refugees reach five years of residence in Switzerland.
The December parliamentary session represents the immediate political decision point, while the planned March 1, 2027, implementation date provides the timetable for the legislative changes.
The proposal forms part of a wider shift in Switzerland’s approach to supporting displaced Ukrainians as temporary protection arrangements enter a longer-term phase.
For Graubünden, the central question is how to maintain financial assistance while limiting the additional burden on cantonal and municipal budgets.
The outcome of the parliamentary debate will determine whether the canton can continue its reduced social assistance system beyond the initial five-year period.
