Swiss Retailers Face a Black Friday Discount Trap as Shoppers Lose Interest
Switzerland’s retailers are heading into the 2026 Black Friday season with a growing problem: increasingly aggressive promotions are not necessarily bringing in more business, while consumers are becoming less impressed by the deals on offer.
An analysis published by the Gottlieb Duttweiler Institute (GDI) on November 12 suggests that the annual discount campaign may be costing Swiss retailers more in reduced product value than it generates in additional purchases. The findings come as forecasts point to broadly stagnant sales for this year’s shopping event, raising questions about whether the increasingly extended promotional season is delivering meaningful growth.
Black Friday falls on November 27 in 2026, followed by Cyber Monday on November 30. But the commercial contest now extends well beyond those dates, with many retailers advertising discounts throughout November.
The arithmetic behind the discount problem
The GDI’s analysis of the 2025 shopping season estimates that Black Friday promotions generated approximately CHF703 million in sales in Switzerland.
At first glance, that is a substantial amount of business. However, the institute’s assessment suggests that the additional spending generated by promotions did not compensate for the revenue retailers surrendered through discounts.
According to the study, purchases that consumers said they would not otherwise have made accounted for an estimated CHF196 million in additional revenue. But shoppers also reported that they would have bought around 72% of the discounted products even without the promotions.
Discounting those purchases was estimated to have reduced the value captured by retailers by approximately CHF291 million. The difference between the two estimates produces a negative balance of around CHF95 million.
These figures describe estimated revenue gains and the value lost through discounts, not audited company profits. They nevertheless illustrate the commercial difficulty of offering price reductions on products customers were already planning to purchase.
The findings also challenge the assumption that a busy shopping period automatically represents a successful one for retailers. A store may sell a large volume of products while earning less revenue than it could have received at normal prices.
Consumers are becoming harder to impress
The GDI’s research points to a parallel problem on the customer side: the promotional event is losing some of its appeal.
In its research covering more than 3,000 consumers in Germany, Austria and Switzerland, the institute found that only 25% of Swiss respondents believed Black Friday deals had become more attractive over the previous five years. Around 40% thought the offers had deteriorated.
More than 90% of Swiss respondents considered the shopping event at least somewhat overrated. Only 9% said they bought more items during Black Friday than they actually needed.
The results suggest that heavy advertising and increasingly lengthy campaigns may be raising expectations that individual offers struggle to meet.
Consumers have become accustomed to seeing promotions before the official shopping day. When discounts are advertised repeatedly, the event itself can lose some of its urgency. Shoppers may also have more time to compare prices across competing retailers rather than making purchases simply because a limited-time sale has been announced.
A separate figure reported in the November 13 coverage found that 32% of respondents described the 2025 Black Friday offers as disappointing, compared with 10% who considered them attractive.
The shopping event is spreading across November
Black Friday’s changing role is also visible in payment data examined by the GDI.
The event originally concentrated consumer activity around a single Friday. Retailers gradually expanded their campaigns, first into longer weekends and then into broader promotional periods. Some now advertise a full month of discounts.
This has changed when consumers spend, without necessarily increasing the total amount they spend during November.
For online non-food retail, the share of November revenue generated on Black Friday itself fell from 20.9% in 2019 to 9.5% in 2025. Meanwhile, the four days from Monday to Thursday before Black Friday became more important, accounting for 21.7% of November revenue, compared with 15.4% previously.
Despite the longer promotional period, November’s share of annual non-food retail revenue barely changed. It stood at 9.4% in 2019 and 9.3% in 2025.
The figures indicate that retailers are spreading sales across more days rather than creating a significantly larger shopping month. GDI Gottlieb Duttweiler Institute
The change also makes competition more difficult. When one retailer begins offering discounts early, rivals may feel pressure to respond. That can lead to a cycle in which companies lower prices to protect their market share, even when the overall market is not expanding.
A cautious outlook for the 2026 campaign
Expectations for this year’s shopping event are restrained.
The shopping platform blackfridaydeals.ch expects Swiss non-food retail turnover on Black Friday to remain around CHF450 million, equivalent to approximately $535 million. The estimate suggests a halt to the decline recorded over the previous two years rather than a major recovery.
The forecast is based on a September 2026 survey conducted by DemoSCOPE among just over 1,000 people in Switzerland.
The survey also points to a shift between online and physical stores. Online non-food retail turnover is expected to increase by CHF10 million to CHF130 million, while sales in traditional high-street shops are projected to fall by a corresponding CHF10 million to CHF320 million.
In total, the two channels would remain at approximately CHF450 million.
Just under one-third of respondents said they planned to shop on Black Friday itself. Consumers aged 15 to 34 showed the strongest interest, with more than half expecting to make a purchase. The survey indicated that younger shoppers tend to compare online offers before deciding where to buy.
These are projections based on survey findings, not confirmed sales results. Actual spending may differ once the promotional period has ended.
Why retailers may struggle to change course
The findings expose a difficult strategic choice for Swiss retailers.
Reducing discounts could protect the value of individual sales, but companies risk losing customers to competitors that continue advertising aggressive promotions. Maintaining large campaigns may preserve visibility and attract shoppers, yet it can also reduce revenue from customers who would have purchased products anyway.
The growing length of the promotional season adds another complication. When discounts become a regular feature of November, customers have less reason to concentrate their spending on one particular day. Retailers may win an earlier purchase from a competitor without generating a new purchase for the wider market.
The GDI’s analysis suggests that individual businesses can find it difficult to escape this cycle because decisions are influenced by the promotional strategies of their competitors.
The research does not establish that every retailer loses money during Black Friday. Results will vary according to product categories, margins, stock levels and the proportion of genuinely additional purchases. Businesses using discounts to clear excess inventory, attract new customers or sell products with strong margins may still benefit.
However, the wider figures indicate that sales volume alone is an inadequate measure of success.
A test of value, not just sales volume
Switzerland’s Black Friday market has become firmly established since major retailers began adopting the US shopping tradition in 2015. Its expansion has helped make November an important period for promotions, but the latest research raises doubts about whether the strategy continues to deliver the benefits retailers originally sought.
For shoppers, the growing number of offers creates more opportunities to compare prices, but it does not guarantee that every advertised discount represents exceptional value. For businesses, the challenge is to attract customers without sacrificing too much revenue on purchases that would have happened anyway.
The November 27 campaign will provide another indication of how consumers respond to the increasingly extended sales season. The more important measure, however, may be whether retailers can turn promotional activity into genuinely additional demand rather than simply shifting purchases between days and discount periods.
